Oneindia - Ramana's Rating: 3
Yeto Vellipoyindi Manasu has superb performance by Nani and Samantha and sound technical elements. But its dragging narration kills the viewers' interest.
Rediff - Radhika Rajamani's Rating: 3
Yeto Vellipoyindi Manasu is packaged with all the right ingredients - a fairly good and sensitive screenplay, fine performances by the lead pair, Nani and Samantha, melodious music by the maestro Ilaiyaraja and decent production values. The film is largely relatable. Yet it is very slow paced and this seems to be the main deterrent.
Hindu - Sangeetha Devi Dundoo's Review
Watch Yeto Vellipoyindi Manasu with the person you love, for there may be many moments you would relate to. A wee bit of patience would help. Stay with the pace of the film and it will reward you with some fine moments in the latter half.
Times of India - Karthik Pasupulate's Rating: 3.5
The movie unfolds at a pace of its own and has very few whistle-moments and has loads of drama. So long as you don't go to the movie expecting another Ye Maya Chesave, you will be fine.
Super Good Movies' Rating: 3.5
Gautham Menon truly deserves the entire credit for his tight screenplay and awesome narration. Best thing about Yeto Vellipoindi Manasu. Soundtrack composed by Ilaiyaraaja. Nani as usual does the role in his style. Samantha is gorgeous in the movie and she pulled off three distinct roles with much ease and her expressions are fabulous.
Bharat Student's Rating: 2.75
The film takes off on a rather slow note and it takes some time to get into the mood. The interval scene was quite lengthy and had few technical hiccups. But the second half gets into some movement and builds the required emotion. As always, the climax was the best part in the entire film. Overall, this is a film which will appeal to those who are in love and who have loved. At the Box Office, it could be an average to below average grosser.
Post Noon - Hemanth Kumar's Rating: 3.5
The pace of narration is slow, but if you overlook that aspect, you'll see what a fine film it is. It's a must-watch if you are a sucker for romance.