Kaminey Review

Thursday, August 13, 2009, 9:48 [IST]
Dhan Te Nan. Vishal Bhardwaj pays homage to cinema of yore and that's reason enough to go out and grab tickets for one of the most keenly anticipated films of our times. A few monsoons ago, Farah Khan paid homage to the cinema of 1970s with Om Shanti OM. Now Bhardwaj picks up characters that we have witnessed on the Hindi screen before, but executes it like Tarantino and Guy Ritchie do. He creates a film that's so different from movies we've witnessed thus far.

Let's say, Kaminey is bold, stark, funny and unpredictable and that's what works in its favour. There're two more reasons: Shahid Kapoor and of course, 'Dhan Te Nan'. Okay, we've seen Shahid pitching in a sincere act in his earlier films, but Kaminey should catapult him to superstardom. His double role in Kaminey is exemplary. There's another star in Kaminey and that's 'Dhan Te Nan'. Your heart starts beating faster every time you hear this in the background or also when Shahid breaks into the song. The track is as big a craze as 'Jumma Chumma' [Hum], 'Ek Do Teen' [Tezaab] and 'Choli Ke Peeche Kya Hai' [Khal-Nayak] and will contribute enormously in attracting viewers in hordes.

Having said that, I wish to add that Kaminey is not the usual masala film. Sure, it's a well-made film, but there's no spoon feeding here. One has to be attentive, very attentive to grasp the goings-on and also the twists in the tale. It's not one of those lock-your-brains-at-home types, for sure. And that might not be too appealing a thought for those who swear by candyfloss or meaningless ha-ha-thons. To cut it short, Kaminey is a film with an attitude. Like it or leave it, but you'd never be able to ignore it. Word from the wise: Go for this hatke experience!

Kaminey is about a pair of twin brothers, Charlie and Guddu [Shahid Kapoor]. Charlie lisps, while Guddu stammers. They are as different as chalk and cheese. And they can't stand the sight of each other. Till one fateful rainy night, their lives cross. Charlie gets mixed up in a deathly get-rich-quick scheme, while Guddu realizes that the love of his life, Sweety [Priyanka Chopra], has unwittingly put a price on his head. The brothers are sucked into a world of drugs, guns and money. Their lives collide head on with the lives of gangsters, rebel soldiers, rogue politicians and crooked cops.

The brothers have to run to protect themselves, their dreams, their love. And most importantly, realize that all they have is each other. It takes time to get used to the world Vishal Bhardwaj wants us to enter. The characters, the relationships, the lingo, the tone and the setting… frankly, you don't take to Kaminey instantly. But twenty minutes into the film and things start falling in place. From thereon, you're drawn into a different world completely. The interval point raises the bar and also the expectations. The story takes a dramatic turn at this juncture, but minutes before that, 'Dhan Te Nan' makes the proceedings exhilarating and stimulating.

Right from the sequence after the interval to the finale, Vishal Bhardwaj peels off layer after layer, which erupts like a volcano towards the end. The end is long drawn and with so many characters in the film, it only takes time to give a culmination to each of those characters. And that gets tedious. The violent end might not find universal acceptance. Vishal Bhardwaj proves that he's a master storyteller. Kaminey is a damn difficult film to conceptualize and execute and Vishal does it with gusto. Besides the soundtrack ['Dhan Te Nan'], the effectual background score only enhances the impact. The dialogues, also penned by Vishal, are super. At places, clapworthy. Tassaduq Hussain's cinematography is top notch.

Shahid takes a really big leap with Kaminey. Note how he handles the two characters, Guddu and Charlie, brilliantly. This film is a step to superstardom and also which will open new doors and vistas for him as an actor. Priyanka is first-rate. She's so much in sync with her character. Also, she gets the Maharashtrian accent perfect. Amole Gupte is outstanding. An incredible actor! Tenzing Nima and Chandan Roy Sanyal leave a solid impression. Shiv Subrahmanyam and Hrishikesh Joshi are perfect.

On the whole, Kaminey lives up to the hype associated with it. The film has three stars -- Vishal Bhardwaj [a name that's immensely respected by moviegoers], Shahid Kapoor and 'Dhan Te Nan' -- and this combo as also the crooked characters and a genuinely hatke subject should guarantee ample footfalls in cineplexes even after its initial weekend. The weekend business should be huge due to the holidays all through the weekend: Friday [Janmashtami], Saturday [Independence Day] and Sunday. Of course, the business is bound to be affected in parts of Mumbai territory due to Swine Flu, but the film should take off in a big way when theatres re-open.
User Comments
Kokila Ben 18 Sep 2009 10:16 am
Pls read A) First! B) whereas Music frees you in certain way... Guddu can speak only when he can observe this freedom... Repeated use of words Matki & Matka is significant as to me it suggests the impermanence & uncertainty of life... Especially of the life of the underworld...!! Similarly the song Dhan ta daan... is also nothing else but the reflection & in a way an ironic celebration of our own internal & external chaos!! The beauty of this film is one can never impose one single/gross meaning on it… it revolves more around the content & the suggestion which is the very idea of any Art itself that it doesn’t bind you to one single meaning but opens in front of you a horizon of possibilities & layers of suggestions.. Many more observations my mind is full of about Kaminey like the taking of the film, technical brilliance, humanness of the characters... Integrality of Music, Wonderful Casting, use of Images like Ghost-Masks while rendering Anti-Aids ( A ghostly disease ) Campaign Song & so on & on… But to conclude for now I would say Kaminey manifests my own Grayness & much, much more! I am going to watch it again! :O))
Kokila Ben 18 Sep 2009 10:14 am
A) I feel happy when I think of a particular set of filmmakers of Contemporary Indian Cinema, the way they are changing the language of cinema is indeed profound! Much Entertainment but at the same time, also Art...!! Truly demanding of a viewer in every respect, doesn’t let you sit laid back... Kaminey is an intense experience! It needs courage to mock at once own self & the family that is my own Indian Cinema & Vishal shows truckloads of it! The way he uses the twin brother story in a completely Non-heroic, Unconventional manner is indeed human & touching! They are humans like us all, full of flaws & incompleteness! Also it is interesting to see when they swap the roles given to them by their destinies & become like the other... Guddu adopts the darkness of Charlie for a while & Charlie becomes fairer as the cinema progresses... Also use of Guitar as a Central Device – a hippie instrument– an instrument which carries everybody’s dream in the film but eventually comes only to the twin bros – the tramps! It signifies invariably that the Dream belongs to the duo and no to the lusty world of gangsters! Also the last gangwar sequence is supported by a melody, a song in stead of some ‘dhishum dhishum’ loud background score; it says a lot about directorial vision – Music brings the Unreal element on the surface.. and it is amazingly shot that the Gangsters trivialize themselves & by trading their own Dream - when actually it is a matter of only One bullet, Yet they go out for this substance-less ‘Sale”! This is precisely the difference between the Gangsters & the Protagonists –the duo chases their Dream but never trades it! Also, I feel Indian Mind IS Musical & it indulges in Music for any and every occasion.. Music truly foregrounds Kaminey.. For instance, as we approach the scene between the cop and Guddu in jail custody, where Guddu can communicate his mind only when he sings.. Language & especially Prose has its own pressure & power on us! Cntd.....
sadia 05 Sep 2009 07:55 am
i really love the movie and the songs!
livi 25 Aug 2009 10:57 am
BEST MOVIE
rohan 24 Aug 2009 11:59 am
I agree with narendra...the film is too fast and noisy....and the storyline isnt that good that it should be rated so generously.many more similar films with almost similar taste and storyline have been produced earlier in INDIA...the only reason why people foolishly gather to watch the film is...the actor himself SHAHID...though he has acted beautifully and have moulded himself perfectly in 2 different characters...the film should have got better thrilling experience so that it could be called as a 'MUST WATCH FLICK'....i wont advise viewers to avoid watching this films...instead i would say...go for it,give it a thought and return back here to key down your views.
Deepak 23 Aug 2009 03:28 pm
Narendra are u mad, this movie is really nice i think u have no sence to watch movies.
Narendra 23 Aug 2009 03:08 pm
Whole movie is shot with close ups and in fast motion....too noisy....no action is virtually seen clearly....not able to understand what is happening....all secens are uncorrelated...need to use brain to a great extent to guess what happened and why...songs looks aweful on those situations......main villain "Bhope" looked like a comedian....can't beleive this is a movie directed by the same director who directed 'Omkara' and 'Maachis'its not only a waste of money but also lost of faith in a good director... Those who have not seen it..please be away from this horrible movie...thanks...its a sincere comments...
Kish 20 Aug 2009 06:26 pm
Not up to the expectations...a below avg movie
kundra 19 Aug 2009 10:38 pm
ofcourse guys this movie is fantastic. the music of this movie is totally mind blowing..... so u must go to cinema to enjoy this amaging movie...
swati 18 Aug 2009 06:59 pm
d movie is too gud guys do watch dis movie after newyork dis is d best movie i hv seen so far dis year
[ Post Comments ]